Saturday, October 25, 2014

Ratnamma of Sai baba's Puttaparthi: her faith mattters



She may be Ratnamma or Muniyamma or Neelamma ... 
Her name hardly matters. I met her during my four-day escape from mundane life in Bangalore to Puttaparthi. As a matter of fact Putaparthi was not in plan as I had been planning to visit Thiruvannamalai.   But unfortunately I could not manage a place for stay owing to the long weekend. I am told  that all accommodations were fully sold out even though my friend and colleague Roshan gave me the number of a place in Thiruvannamalai. The next place came to my mind was Puttaparthi: The Land of Saibaba.

The journey is part of my next level of artistic enquiry on human utopia, the epitome of human faith:  God.  For the last thirty-eight and odd years, ever since I saw Theyyam for the first time, where my friend’s father turned into a God for day,  has been an intriguing question in my life.  Otherwise lookdown upon as a cast dalit and poor, my friend’s father became a subject of worship on that day for all: the high and mighty.  

Over the years after many experiences and explorations I realised in my limited understanding that every faith on earth has been an effort in that direction: the social elevation of the deprived.  It insists the compassion and love: the social equity, order and justice; the human utopia for that men formed groups, communities, religions, nations and structure then fought and killed !.

From Socrates’s insistence on inherent social order from early Greek period to St. Augustine, the monotheistic journey was wound up temporarily with my MA thesis dissertation on pieta, where the idea of gender and God was explored. Now it is the turn of polytheism from Kapila’s  Prakriti  and purusha  through  Pathanjali’s yogasutra concept  of salvation to Godhood to Ratnamma at Puttaparthi, the enquiry is on.

From the day I reached Puttaparthi, I saw her on the pavement leading to Prashanthi Nilayam, where Sai baba used to give his everyday audience to his disciples.  The old lady had wrinkled marks of years of turbulent living embedded all over her body.  What I found interesting about her was in the evening while I was returning after the arathi at Prashanti nilayam, I saw this lady giving away all her leftover fruits to street kids. Thereafter she slowly walked up to temple gate to pray before vanishing into the dark.  Although tired with my long drive and atmospheric heat, still I waited and watched  her act silently. The next day morning on my way back to the hall I saw her at the same spot again, trying her hard bargain with customers. I bought couple of oranges from her, although I knew she was charging me excess, I did not bargain her much.

But in the evening while I was coming back to hotel,  I saw her sitting at the same place and she had two oranges in her hand and called me in Hindi “ Babu ye lelo…subai mein jyaada liya  aapse” ( babu take this, in the morning I took excess from you) she thought I am a north Indian.

All I could do was with a courtesy smile refuse her oranges. But she also refused to give up, pointing at Prashanti nilayam and said “nai babu, bhagvan maaf nahin karega”, she laid out in front of me the fundamental value of money: the ethical profit.  Thus began our conversation.

Ratnamma was not as old as I believed; she was only in her early sixties.  She is coming from the Naxal belt of Andhra Pradesh.  Her husband was a naxalite  killed in police encounter.  She had three sons and two daughters.  Eldest one also continued his father’s path, one became alcoholic and died with  liver cirrhosis, and the third one ran away without any trace. With two daughters to look after, with nothing to piggybank, she migrated to Vijayawada and became a sex worker.  The elder one ran away with a pimp and the younger one married and settled in Vijayawada.  After her daughter’s marriage a pimp brought her here at Puttaparthi for trade and since then she is settled here. But according to her, with her first chanced audience with Sai baba, she stopped her sex work forever and became a fruit seller instead.

Her story may not be different from millions others floating around every city roads in this country.  I did not take those oranges from her and asked her to give them to those children she regularly feeds.  She smiled with her wrinkled frail face. 

On my way back to hotel her story haunted my mind. 
Who is Ratnamma after all? 
During the last sixty years of her life, this country has transformed from Gandhian idealism to Nehruvian socialism to a Narasimha rao’s capitalism (and since then everybody’s including the present government’s) with much fanfare and propaganda and in the end, in Ratnamma’s family of seven, only one person could  secure and settle a life with little dignity.  She may be Ratnamma or Muniyamma or Neelamma and  it hardly matters.  The story of vast majority in this country is not different. All those political utopias have failed to deliver its intended objective: the social elevation of the deprived.  They always reminded these poor that they had to sacrifice for a better tomorrow, they had to tighten their belts for a better tomorrow, they had to overthrow power for a better tomorrow or they had to give away their homes and land for a better tomorrow.  But after more than sixty years of  independence,  with all their sufferings, India still produces millions of Ratnammas everywhere in this country. Ratnamma’s  are kept on losing their dignity and family for politics, economics and survival.

Suddenly the three-line vibhoothi and the vermilion spot on her forehead became prominent in front of my eyes.  So was the Sai baba and many other saints and Sufis.  When the rationality of politics, its economics nitty-gritties and its pragmatic administrations failed to deliver the much-needed human dignity to these millions of Ratnammas, these Sai babas, Ramana Maharshis and Amruthanandamayies reassures them it in abundance. For our rational intellectuals it may sound foolish, but one cannot overlook the fact they they give Ratnammas the dignity and reassurance to carry on their life with  the right for an ethics of their belief.

If we look at her life’s story, she is a martyr’s wife, the communists have forgotten and she is a women business entrepreneur,  the capitalists in this  country will ever   bother worth considering as a business  and she is a citizen of this democratic country, where her fellow citizens have chosen to abuse  her body and take away her dignity.  
It is people like Sai baba gives her that personal solace.  
I went to puttaparthi looking for a person and came back knowing a God through Ratnamma.  For me his magic of creating Vibhuthi or garland hardly matters anymore as it matter for the rational minds. For my irrational mind, the intent of his deed is all that matters.  
The 2500-kilo meter water distribution system he created for water deprived rural Andhra Pradesh matters.  
His hospital for free heart surgeries for poor matters. 
The free educational institutions created across India and Africa matters.
The township come-up around his activity alone, where thousands of Kashmiri youth’s found job opportunity in handicraft sales and people like Ratnamma who finally finds a dignified existence in life matters.  

As an artist I always prefer image over sentence for its ability to engage multilaterally as against the linearly structured grammatically ordered sentences.

Ratnamma slowly emerges as one of those artistic images in front of my eyes : the Faith of  polytheistic God.
.


Sunday, October 19, 2014

The signs are on the air:the omens of Capitalist transformation and Maharashtra election : alarm bell rings for BJP

As the dust settles down, in comparison to 2014 general election, the victory of Maharashtra and Haryana sadly does not leave much room for BJP to be euphoric. After fifteen years of ruling by congress- ncp coalition, along with anti incumbency, BJP could only dent 3% vote share from congress. ( 21.01 % (82) seat in 2009 to 17.9 % (42) seat in 2014) in Maharashtra.
In spite of BJP's campaigned against NCP as naturally corrupt party, they in fact gained from their 2009 tally of 16.37% to 17.3% in 2014.
So is Shivsena who gained from its 16.26% (33) in 2009 to double the seat count (63) with 19.4% vote share.
In other words effectively traditional party voters haven't changed their loyalty in this state of industrial money power and also they seems to have not bought BJP's campaign of removing corrupt congress- ncp alliance.
So the BJP's 27.8 % vote share gain from 14.02% from 2009 represents the new aspirational India's vote who believe Mr.Modi's offer of stable development promising government. With or without the support of NCP or Shivsena to cover the crucial majority margin this looks like not a realistic possibility given the political track record of Maharashtra.
Traditionally Conservative Haryana's change of mind need not be taken seriously as congress met out much worst scenario twice before in this state and this time an anti robert vadra vote: that is all. The translation of economically rich and highly cast conservative Haryana’s tectonic shift as a permanent political realignment can wait for long time.
Keeping all these factors along with the recent loss of by elections within 3 months of sweeping in general election, the time is not yet ripe for BJP to claim the Congress mukta Bharat. The core party base of congress is still remain intact across the country. It is only hurt. With its "leave it for now to settle down the anger and wait for 2019" policy, congress can make a serious comeback if BJP doesn't build the party base and want to continue only on anti congress feeling( that anyway people are going to forget and pardon in couple of years.)
Let us not forget in this era of globalized economy to take the development and economic progress to these emerging young aspirational voters within five years is beyond the means of any realistic imagination. UPA1 and 2 are the classic example for that.
There is a big conflict of dignity of human and idea of development taking place in rural India. Historically this is an unavoidable transition of Industrialisation in any society. Parallels can be drawn from the conflicts during European renaissance and its transformation story. They overcame this issue through the idea of welfare society by economic subsidisation of life to protect human dignity so that the citizen doesn't lose belief in the economic model and reject it.
At the fag end of its second term UPA 2 was forced to take the same route by announcing so many welfare programs to sustain the capitalistic economic growth model. This another unavoidable process of capitalism has just begun. If Mr. Modi has to sustain his capitalist development agenda, he will have to reassure the public that his model does not conflict with their dignity. He will have to dispel the disbelieve now exist between people and corporates. BJP will have to economically subsidise the lives of the voters through welfare means and methods, that the Indian corporates believes as waste. Mr. Modi will have to convince the corporates the pet named Philanthropy as an essential poly, if capitalism wants to sustain in democracy. In a political democracy dignity of human is what the profit to the corporate in capitalism.
If his actions are to be believed, Mr. Modi realises this issue, as he seems to be furthering UPA2's welfare policies with toilet and swatch bharat projects etc. and also his reluctance to intervene on the controversial land act (the much publicised so called rahul gandhi's land act) tells no other story.
But how far the business who supported BJP against the UPA 2's welfare policies are going take it is the big question remain unanswered, especially considering family based crony capitalism is still thriving as a practical model of capitalism in this country.
As a politician Mr. Modi and the BJP unfortunately stands at this usual cross road of a transforming country that has to tread cautiously between welfare state and capitalism. Also human dignity is an ambiguous complex mechanism highly intertwined within economic stability, faith and anger. If any one of these fail then other two also will fail. History of human civilisation is the complete evidence of the same.
The capitalistic inroad to human settlements in this country to derive profit, tactically interpreted as economic liberalisation, if not supported with welfare means to the affected, is going to unleash catastrophic consequences in the days ahead.(considering the conflict is on the rise between industry and citizens in every state. The maoist problem, Anna hazare movement, emergence of AAP, emotional hype on Black money issue and the middle class resurgence against congress’s failed leadership to tackle corporate corruption that BJP encashed as turned into Mr. Modi’s charisma are only the indication of that . BJP will have to recognise this reality as early as possible, if they want to remain in power, more so because this time BJP used the capitalistic tool of treating the voters as consumers by selling their aspirations as a product back to them. It is the market order that every product comes with a price and expiry date.
As discussed above the indignity of economic instability in human life always leads to the issues of faith and fundamentalism then anger and finally to the collapse of system. Communism and its counterpart American war mongering capitalism across the world tell no other story.
BJP should rise above these foolish rhetorics of "congress mukt bharat" and patriotic chest thumping and acknowledge these facts of an economically transforming democracy: an act unfortunately a cadre based party has never made it in the history and will not ever be able to circumvent.
If BJP does not want the fate of UPA 2 and become the victim of the intricacies of economic transformation of a democratic country to capitalism, they should debunk those economists who are championing against welfare interventions in capitalistic inroads. Welfare and capitalism are in separable. If BJP believe those economist’s argument that once capitalism blossom the charity will automatically trickle in, although sounds practical, unfortunately had always been unrealistic. The blossoming process already would have broken down the faith of citizen about the intend of proft and the idea of business. The consequential anger will undo the system, remember the emergence of Marxist economy and communism, identity politics of Mussolini, Hitler, Tajo, and two world wars were its outcome. Also UPA2 faced this tune, the mass agitation and anger against so called inapte government and massive corporate corruption, what BJP encased upon in 2014 general election is only a step in that process
 if they don't realise the importance of socio-economic intervention people will throw them out as well.

Thursday, September 25, 2014

migratory birds and a map

It is a strange feeling
A pain, at the end of long encounters
city roads, buildings, people
The text I read through the only language I know: colours
I think at last  I know what am I in this city.
The city, like every other city I left behind
Like every men I met in every city
A strange feeling
A map that becomes plots
Plots that become buildings
Buildings that become houses
Houses that become homes
Homes that become...

Map that become plots
Plots that become buildings
Buildings that become houses
Houses that become homes
Homes that become
The strange feeling
The city
The end of innocent encounters....

Sunday, August 17, 2014

What is the lie when art is turning into a mela toy?

 Glass Facade - Acrylic on canvas,2014

“..though the manifestations of every lie remains an inconclusive decision between beholder and beneficiary but when our comprehension turns into apprehension, the  intend for a lie strongly emerges in every mind…”


If we consider, a lie as a perpetual state of denial of facts, the idea of experimentation will then become an act of perjury since quite often than more iterative minds need to deny rational facts for the benefit of experimentation or the exploratory imagination.   This complex metamorphosis of human adventure operationalised under perceived notion of ethical and moral societal rule of law;  will result at times as a counterproductive interruptions in cohesive social order, as the lie becomes an empirical fact of life than the subjective notions of  truth.

If we consider society as a regimented order of civilisation, from time immemorial, society’s fear for lie and obsession with truth and rule of law tells no other story. Society while emphasizes on truth and rule of law through stagnant structuration of citizenship and religious morality, the evolutionary process society unfortunately shapes up through a pattern of experimentation, where breakdown is expected and failure is embedded.

This complex layering of human life: the need for adventurous to be progressive and stagnancy of structuring for existence, better understood as  the conflict between orthodox and liberal, unfortunately survive on our apprehension or fear. Moreover  though the manifestations of every lie remains an inconclusive decision between beholder and beneficiary  but as and when our comprehension turns into apprehension, the intention for a lie start strongly  emerge in every mind.  Complexity of this layering become many fold,  when we realise that the apprehensive society also  appropriates lie for its sustenance. In human history, there are enough evidence where state and religious establishments appropriating these cards of imaginatives; a constructive narratives of myth,  where “human adventure of truth triumphing over the destructive evil lie “ first as a methodology and then to propel a regimented social structure of stagnant society.  Considering myths are to society is  axioms to science, where rationality of truth  only a means of practicality,  lie  becomes a subjective truth.

Even if we  leave these complex layering of truth and lie to philosophical interpolations, the unstoppable nature of the evolutionary  human progress does not allow us to   overlook  the   essentiality of adventure in liberal imagination and  the need of moral orthodoxy appropriate a lie to sustain the notions of truth.   

This is not different from the issue of relationships in human life between one to one, one to many and many to many, where structuration of locating oneself from individual, one of the many and one among many to our and collective through the narratives of myths about faith, believe and trust.  This is a negotiated space where one has to confront with oneself as an individual and community through either structure or adventure that are defined by a context.  Here the context can be defined as individual, subject, object, objective, collective, community, any one of them or all of them together.  Considering  adventure need not rely upon narratives of facts and truth, the differentiation of truth and lie becomes evidently blurred and vulnerable. From time immemorial, construct of human expression-the art,  has always been playing this major role of subjectivity of truth and lie in societal structure and its challenge.  
Leaving aside the narrative ritualistic forms of  aboriginal art, art during the last hundred years has been  a life of an orchestrated narrative. From Dada movement during early nineteenth century onwards the art is said to have been undergoing through many experimentations and manifestations raising the question of what makes art and what is not!

 Critically  we assess the art scene of 20th and 21st century, we will find  the curious aspect of art practice that has emerged around the world that  the scenario of art practice  is  not  same as the holy gospel of art prophecies about art viewer, art and artist.  There are these  multiple layers of establishments, Galleries/Museums, Agents, printers, fliers, catalogues, news media/art magazines, internet and social network, critics, Exhibitions, auction houses, art fairs, biennales, funding agencies, bankers, residencies, academics, market and its curators stand between the  work  of art and the viewer.  Moreover quite often than more, owing to their delivery commitments,  these days mainstream artists  mostly outsource the production of their artwork to artisans specialised skill sets  and the same are presented as genuine and original with authorship by segregating the authorship of idea and creation.  For the benefit of this process, it is theoretically argued that authorship of idea is the  art and the authorship of creation  is only a secondary craft.  This issue of authorship becomes even more complicated when curators are involved in the artistic production, as curators develop and outsource the artistic idea to artist who in turn outsource the production  of work of art to artisan and who then  creates the work of art . Here the layers between the artwork and art viewer becomes highly complicated and blurred.

Art viewing also does not remain the same anymore.  From the easily accessible mass circulated books and computer monitors to the crowds of art fairs, art viewing now has the range of paradigm shift between intensive Internet viewing to the crowd gathering at art melas. 

                                                                                                                                          Cont….